After a hiatus of many years, I’m collecting baseball cards again. But only a certain kind of card.
These cards. The 2017 Topps Heritage cards, which are based on the 1968 Topps card design. That year, 1968, was when an 11-year-old kid in Wisconsin really got into collecting cards for the first time.
Some of the players in the 2017 set are new to me, but there’s a wonderfully comforting feeling to being introduced to them in such a familiar way. I’m enjoying it.
It’s the same feeling I get when I play basketball, just shooting hoops by myself. Been doing that since I was about 11, too. I step onto that court and the years just seem to fall away.
Likewise record digging. There’s something wonderfully comforting about an experience that’s essentially the same today as it was in the earliest ’70s in Sheboygan, Wisconsin.
Flash back to 1970, and there is 13-year-old me carefully examining the 45s in the record department in the basement of Prange’s department store or in the rack near the checkout at the Evans variety store. Then I’d look through the LPs, which seemed unattainable, far beyond my allowance.
One of my earliest 45s was “American Woman” by the Guess Who on that great orange RCA label. The flip side, “No Sugar Tonight,” turned out to be the Guess Who’s next single. You know that version, but here are two less-heard covers. They come via fellow bloggers, which is another of the joys of record digging, getting tipped to things you might not otherwise hear.
“No Sugar Tonight,” the Shirelles, from “Happy and In Love,” 1971, also on RCA. Thank you to Vincent the Soul Chef for this. Once a blogger, Vincent now serves up his Fufu Stew on Mixcloud. It’s from a fine mix called “Records Are Like Chocolate … The Revenge!”
“No Sugar Tonight,” Steel Wool, from the single on White Whale Records, 1970. Steel Wool is one of the aliases used by singer and drummer Buddy Randell, who’d left the Knickerbockers that year. Thank you to Andrew, the proprietor over at Armagideon Time, for this. It’s from one of his anniversary mixes.
Postscript: My rediscovery of baseball cards brings with it one age-old problem. I’ve bought about 100 cards, yet have gotten only one Brewers player so far. Seems like it’s the hunt for Cookie Rojas all over again.
AM, Then FM 
The best thing Topps has done lately is to resuscitate its old card designs. It’s catnip for collectors of a certain age.
I too rarely seem to get the team I am looking for. Perhaps that is an unwritten rule of pack buying. Call it Shlabotnik’s Law.
Always loved the Guess Who’s version of this song… but never heard the other two renditions. And I love the connection to the Knickerbockers!
Thanks Jeff!
Sir,
I’m glad you are determined to keep writing.
If you like baseball cards, you would enjoy the writing of Josh Wilker and his blog, Cardboard Gods. And no better introduction for a Brewer’s fan that this entry inspired by Gorman Thomas, and more generally about the late 70’s-early-80’s Brew Crew.
In closing, please please tell me the that Brewers are going back to the awesome old “MB” logo…please? Their current unis look like a softball team sponsored by the local Bennigan’s. Only the Padres (whose logo looks like a suburban “Wild Waves Water Park”) are more generic and boring.
I really enjoy your writing. Thank you.